8

Rupa(form): Patavi (earth element or hardness/softness) Apo (water element or cohesion) Tejo (fire element or heat/cold) Vayo (air element or motion) 24 secondary elelments Vedana(feeling) bodily agreeable feeling bodily painful feeling mentally agreeable feeling mentally painful feeling indifferent feeling Sanna(perception) perception of form ...


6

In some realms there are some beings who are not aware of their own existence (Some place in Brahma realm). How do their aggregates work when they themselves aren't aware of their existence? Unconscious beings (asannasatta) has consciousness suppressed temporarily until their life span ends. Due to this they cannot be aware of anything including themselves. ...


6

The same terms are often used at a "microscopic-view" level, at a "day-to-day-view" level and at a "macro-view". This leads to a lot of confusion. According to the Abhidhamma, feeling / sensation / experience (vedanā) and perception / recognition (saññā) arise simultaneously in every Thought Moment (cittakhaṇa). The Abhidhamma looks at things at a "...


6

This is the problem with mixing up ultimate reality with conventional reality. In ultimate reality, the cat does not exist. What is real is the tactile experience of the touch. That experience is an instance of the 5 aggregates arising due to causes. The experience is impermanent, unsatisfactory and non-self. 'Container' is only a concept in the mind. It ...


4

We can't see five aggregates as it is. We can see a men, animals, Devas. Or good thing, bad thing. Or a beautiful thing, a ugly thing etc. But in reality, there is nothing like that. Everything just a thing or collection of several things. We only making things matter to us. Nothing else. Refer this answer. If we took a tower build by stones, actually ...


4

"Aggregate" in "Five Aggregates" is a common translation of the Sanskrit word "skandha" or Pali "khandha". Other translations of skandha include "heap", "group", "collection". The image for this is a heap of firewood. In the metaphor of fire (SN 35.28), in which dukkha is compared with burning, and liberation (nirvana) is compared with extinguishing, the ...


3

Due to past fabrication resulting from past experiences is instruments in creating the current conciousness. As conciousness cannot exist without a body this creates current body with each of the relevant sense faculties associated with the different consciousness. The faculties in the current body which come in contact with external objects. The ...


3

Nothing happens to that person when consciousness ceases - there was never a person to begin with, only arising and ceasing of experience. I realized after the fact that I can't sufficiently cite sources while on my phone - apologies for such an incomplete answer, I'll try and expand later :)


2

5 Aggregates can be consider as a combination of vinnana & namarupa. Some times the Dependent Origination is consider as a cycle. Past Life, present life and next life formation. Also it can used to show the continuity of the thought sequence. Generally it take avijja(ignorance) - not knowing things(Sunya) correctly - as the starting point - the ...


2

1.Khandha/aggregate definition If I am not wrong, the aggregates are called aggregates because they are the sum total of many heterogenous things taken together. Khandha-word is used in tipitaka 3 meaning: gather of uncountable dukkha, wholesome-dukkha, and paṇṇatti of dukkha. Khandha, which translated as aggregate, is gather of uncountable dukkha as ...


2

Your question is a variation of the question, "if there is no self, then who is responsible for actions?" The Buddha rubbished the notion that there is no self doing anything, in the Attakari Sutta: “Venerable Gotama, I am one of such a doctrine, of such a view: ‘There is no self-doer, there is no other-doer.’” (“Natthi attakāro, natthi parakāro.”) ...


2

From the Mahanidana Sutta (DN15): "If one is asked, 'From what requisite condition does contact come?' one should say, 'Contact comes from name-and-form as its requisite condition.' "If one is asked, 'From what requisite condition does name-and-form come?' one should say, 'Name-and-form comes from consciousness as its requisite condition.' ...


2

Is government a physical object? I imagine the 5 aggregates happening within a frame, which is a different one for every living creature. Governments can shape "actions of the country", but in the physical sense there are no such objects like "government" or "state". There is this frame, this perspective, which is unique for any of us, starts at birth,...


2

Just as, with an assemblage of parts, The word 'chariot' is used, So, when the aggregates are present, There's the convention 'a being.' https://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/bodhi/bl143.html


2

In your question you say, "it is not possible to separate them or delineate them or disjoin them." But Ven. Thanissaro's translation says: "It is not possible, having separated them one from another, to delineate the difference among them." So the first point of contention is: is it possible to separate them [feeling, perception, ...


2

Does nirodha samapatti aka saññā-vedayita-nirodha refer to a super trance-like state beyond the 8th jhana in which the practitioner becomes completely unconscious without any mental activity (like what the commentary above suggests) with cessation of ALL perception and feeling? Yes. Or does nirodha samapatti aka saññā-vedayita-nirodha refer to Nibbana-...


1

There are only two realities: saṅkhāra (dependent origination such as aggregate) and asaṅkhāra (no dependent origination such as nibbāna). All others are paññatti (concept;imagine;not reality) because saṅgkhāra must have tree sub-characteristics and asaṅkhāra must have not tree sub-characteristics. But paññatti has nothing, it can't arise like saṅkhāra and ...


1

I need much better examples for the other four aggregates I guess a non-canonical example for "perception" might be, imagine you're living somewhere: a city or a village, a house. And you're there, you live there, for a long time. And you see it frequently. And sometimes when you see it (see a bit of it, a familiar sight) you may think, "this ...


1

In dependant origination, Vinnana refers to the Patisandhi Citta. In other words, the first Bhavaanga citta in your current life. This is way before the senses are developed. Consciousness aggregate refers to awareness aspect of the sensory experiences. In other words; the eye consciousness, ear consciousness, nose consciousness etc. The mind and body ...


1

The five aggregates are the factors / activities that make up a "being", what is conventionally called a self. Dependent origination is the set of natural laws that keep a "being" bound to samsara (cycle of rebirth). So one could say that the five aggregates continue to exist from one existence to the next due to the natural law of dependent origination.


1

From my understanding they are called aggregates not necessarily because they are made of something. Its because they are described in plural. For example 'Foam Aggregate' is translated from Rupa Skandha, meaning the aggregate of Rupa or aggregated rupa. Same goes for other 4 as well. Also asking what they are made of in general sense might not even be ...


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible