0

It is not necessarily but I wonder what would happen if monk will meditate in "anechoic" chamber?

The Orfield Labs room was recognized as the quietest in the world

If you stand in it for long enough, you start to hear your heartbeat.
A ringing in your ears becomes deafening. When you move, your bones make a grinding noise.
Eventually you lose your balance, because the absolute lack of reverberation sabotages your spatial awareness.

Here is link

There will be -20db silence in the room.
So may we know how much db of silence (internally) is produced while mediating?

So will monk be able to meditate in this room or he will suffer the effect of it?

When we can hear heartbeat, bones grinding noise will he able to concentrate on breathing and could meditate without suffering?

  • Is there any reason to believe that skandhas are different in that chamber, compared to life outside of it? – Erik Mar 30 at 13:20
  • Wouldn't be different and when enters in jhana. – Swapnil Mar 30 at 14:44
1

I don't think it really matters. When I meditate, sometimes I hear a car passing or a bird singing or a child laughing in the distance; sometimes I hear a scrap of music in my head, dredged up from some distant memory; sometimes I hear the sound of my breathing, or my heart beating, or the creak of a joint as my body settles. These are just sounds, of no particular importance. They come and they go. For someone unpracticed in meditation that kind of silence would be disorienting, because the outer silence exposes all of their inner noise. But meditation reaches for inner quietness.

| improve this answer | |
  • But meditation reaches for inner quietness. that's why I thought it is possible to meditate. There will be -20 db silence so may we need to know how much db silence is produced while meditation. – Swapnil Mar 31 at 13:57
  • @Swapnil: inner quietness is a mental state, not a question of volume that's measure in decibels. it's a state in which we aren't reactive to disturbances of the mind, whether that means intrusive external noises or intrusive mental conditions brought on by the lack of external noise. – Ted Wrigley Mar 31 at 14:17
  • @@Ted Wrigley Thank you so much. Now I've got. – Swapnil Mar 31 at 14:21
3

Yes in a video ajahn brahm said that ajahn chah went into such a room. I think he said there was nothing special according to ajahn Chah. The video was some Q&A, but you can ask for more on his forum https://bswa.org/forum/

| improve this answer | |
  • I'll ask Ajahn Brahm personally if ti is done by Ajahn Chah. Thank you so much. – Swapnil Mar 31 at 14:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.