3

The quote below defines Vitarka-vicara as:

  • Ardency (atappa) + mindfulness (sati) => combines to make vitakka
  • Ardency (atappa) + alertness (sampajañña) => combines to make vicara

As Ajaan Lee, my teacher’s teacher, once noted, mindfulness combined with ardency turns into the concentration factor called vitakka, or directed thought, where you keep your thoughts consistently focused on one object, such as the breath. Alertness combined with ardency turns into another concentration factor: vicāra, or evaluation

Head & Heart Together, by Ṭhānissaro Bhikkhu, Chapter: Mindfulness Defined

No citation from the cannon have been given in this discussion.

What are the Tipitaka, commentary, sub commentary sources, including primary, secondary or tertiary source with citations, which defines Vitarka-vicara as such?

Are there other definitions of Vitarka-vicara from Tipitaka, commentaries, sub commentaries, including primary, secondary or tertiary source with citations?

5

See SN 46.3 http://lucid24.org/sn/sn46/sn46-003/index.html

  1. sati-sambojjhanga remembers Dhamma-teaching, then thinks (vitakka) about that Dharma.
  2. Dhamma-vicaya-sambojjhnaga investigates that Dharma-teaching recollected by sati, by means of vicara (evaluation) paññāya (same word as the sampajano, what B. thanissaro translates as 'alertness').

ātāpi = ardency, is equivalent to the 3rd awakening factor vigor/viriya, also equivalent to 4 aspects of right effort.

So what Ajahn Lee is saying sounds idiosyncratic at first, but it is solidly based on EBT sutta.

  • SN 46.3 very good. However, the claims about Ajahn Lee solidly based on EBT sutta is questionable. – Dhammadhatu Sep 4 at 21:46
5

From Khuddaka Nikaya's The Questions of King Milinda (translation mine):

‘Venerable Nagasena, what is the characteristic mark of vitakka*?’

‘The characteristic mark of vitakka is "placing" (Appanā), Your Majesty.’

‘Give me an example.’

‘For example, Your Majesty, like a carpenter takes well-finished boards of wood and places (appeti) them in position.’

Mil 3.3.13

*ideation, reasoning, putting forward ideas, postulating a premise


‘Venerable Nagasena, what is the characteristic mark of vicāra*?’

‘The characteristic mark of vicāra is pondering/mulling over (anumajjana), Your Majesty.’

‘Give me an example.’

‘For example, Your Majesty, if you strike on a copper vessel, it then rings for a while, it responds with a sound. Here, Your Majesty, the strike is a simile for vitakka and the reverberation is a simile for vicāra.’

Mil 3.3.14

*investigating a premise, considering an idea to weigh its implications

  • Do you know where it says Ardency (atappa) + mindfulness (sati) => combines to make vitakka and Ardency (atappa) + alertness (sampajañña) => combines to make vicara. Also which section and page do the above come from? – Suminda Sirinath S. Dharmasena Sep 4 at 12:27
  • 3
    Vitakka here: suttacentral.net/mil3.3.13/en/tw_rhysdavids Very good, Guru Volkov. Thank you for this. – Dhammadhatu Sep 4 at 12:43
  • 2
    @SumindaSirinathS.Dharmasena RE: atappa, I think the meaning is, not any vitakka, but the right arya vitakka is ardent mindfulness of dharma (sati), and right arya vicara is ardent "clear awareness that comes from having penetrated dharma" (sampajanna). In other words, ardently thinking about dharma is proper vitakka, and ardently keeping overall dharmic awareness is proper vicara. – Andrei Volkov Sep 4 at 19:18
0

I think the citations from SN 46.3 and the Milindapañha provided in the other answers are sufficient for answering this question.

However, it think they may not explain the meaning of vitakka & vicara in respect to jhana, let alone in respect to samadhi, because Ajahn Lee Dhammadharo's ideas would imply there is ardency (atappa) in the 1st jhana and no ardency (atappa) in the 2nd, 3rd and 4th jhanas.

However, MN 111 does not distinguish any different supporting mental factors among the different jhanas. Also, MN 19, for example, appears to say a meditator abiding in the 4th jhana has ardency (atappa), however subtle, indirect and/or automatic:

With the giving up of pleasure and pain, and the ending of former happiness and sadness, I entered and remained in the fourth absorption, without pleasure or pain, with pure equanimity and mindfulness.

Sukhassa ca pahānā dukkhassa ca pahānā pubbeva somanassadomanassānaṃ atthaṅgamā adukkhamasukhaṃ upekkhāsatipārisuddhiṃ catutthaṃ jhānaṃ upasampajja vihāsiṃ.

When my mind had immersed in samādhi like this—purified, bright, flawless, rid of corruptions, pliable, workable, steady, and imperturbable — I extended it toward recollection of past nivāsā.

So evaṃ samāhite citte parisuddhe pariyodāte anaṅgaṇe vigatūpakkilese mudubhūte kammaniye ṭhite āneñjappatte pubbenivāsānussatiñāṇāya cittaṃ abhininnāmesiṃ. I recollected many kinds of past lives, with features and details.

So anekavihitaṃ pubbenivāsaṃ anussarāmi. Seyyathidaṃ—ekampi jātiṃ … pe … iti sākāraṃ sauddesaṃ anekavihitaṃ pubbenivāsaṃ anussarāmi.

This was the first knowledge, which I achieved in the first watch of the night. Ayaṃ kho me, bhikkhave, rattiyā paṭhame yāme paṭhamā vijjā adhigatā;

Ignorance was destroyed and knowledge arose; darkness was destroyed and light arose, as happens for a meditator who is diligent, keen, and resolute.

avijjā vihatā vijjā uppannā; tamo vihato āloko uppanno; yathā taṃ appamattassa ātāpino pahitattassa viharato.

MN 19


In my personal experience, vitakka & vicara in respect to samadhi are not as Ajahn Lee Dhammadharo proposed because mindfulness & sampajjana have no direct relationship to vitakka & vicara. Any relationship is merely an indirect consequence that fades in the 2nd jhana.

The function of mindfulness in respect to samadhi development is to maintain sampajjana (situational wisdom), which culminates in keeping the mind free from unwholesome states and making the mind still. Mindfulness establishes a centre point or 'anchor' for the mind.

The result of this mindful stilling of ordinary mental activity is consciousness automatically begins to flow towards or get involved with/land on (upaya; appatiṭṭha; refer to SN 22.53) the in & out breathing.

This automatic non-volitional movement of consciousness towards the breathing is 'vitakka'. The tracking & hugging (anumajjana - lit: 'rubbing') of the breathing by consciousness (which allows the experiencing, feeling & evaluating of the breathing) is 'vicara'.

In the 1st jhana, there remains some subtle movement of consciousness towards (vitakka) and exploration (vicara) of the factors of the 1st jhana, which Ajahn Brahm has described in his book (linked below) as the "Jhana Wobble". However, this vitakka (movement towards) & exploration/ looking around (vicara) cease in the 2nd jhana, where the mind is perfectly still (ekodibhāvaṃ).

Ajahn Buddhadasa said (page 203-204):

enter image description here

Bhikkhu Sujato noted on page 169:

...in some Buddhist works, vitakka and vicāra ‘are apparently looked upon as special faculties in the first jhāna, not as mere thought remaining from ordinary consciousness’.

Ajahn Brahm said on PDF page 30:

Some commentators explain the pair, vitakka and vicára as “initial thought” and “sustained thought.” While in other contexts this pair can refer to thought, in jhana they certainly mean something else.

enter image description here

  • 1
    It is clear to me as sky on a bright sunny day, what Vitakka and Vicara in jhanas mean. They mean that the first jhana is achieved with help of deliberate reflection used as a kind of autosuggestion, and the subsequent jhanas do not involve this. – Andrei Volkov Sep 5 at 1:49
  • Sorry but no Andrei. SN 48.10. Jhana born from letting go/surrender (vossagga). The only volition is letting go rather than thrusting/poking/pushing like when a man has sex. Its like a woman using volition to open her vagina. No hammer on nail or hitting a bell or anything like that. Its not macho. – Dhammadhatu Sep 5 at 2:50
  • 1
    Yeah, in the first jhana it is letting go of the craving for and aversion to worldly experiences. This is what autosuggestion type of reflection is used for. Then the second jhana is exactly letting go of these autosuggestions. No vagina. Try it. – Andrei Volkov Sep 5 at 11:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.