Do thoughts have energy or they are in a energy field? During meditation when thoughts are there experience high energy and when the mind is calm experience less energy.

  • 1
    By energy, do you mean motivation, confidence and high spirits? Or do you mean like electrical or electromagnetic energy? Or perhaps psychic energy? – ruben2020 May 13 '18 at 15:26
  • Electromagnetic energy – user12686 May 13 '18 at 15:41
  • Thought is not a well defined scientific concept. If you restrict yourself to the biochemistry of the brain, then yes the brain converts energy into work from a physical perspective. I'm marking the question down as it is not a question about Buddhism and mixes concepts from science with ill-defined concepts not pertinent to that field. – Yeshe Tenley Jun 13 '18 at 16:34

There's no such thing as "Electromagnetic energy" from a Vipassana(insight) meditator's point of view in Buddhism. It's all just seeing, hearing, smelling ,tasting, touching, thinking.

  • How do you know – user12686 May 13 '18 at 16:21
  • Read the Sabba sutta and the Bahiya Sutta – Sankha Kulathantille May 13 '18 at 16:23
  • What about Bermuda triangle. It's all energy you have ultimately. During cessation can experience this. I suppose. – user12686 May 13 '18 at 16:33
  • Bermuda triangle doesn't exit to a meditator. Energy doesn't exist. – Sankha Kulathantille May 13 '18 at 17:08
  • What do you mean by energy doesn't exist – user12686 May 13 '18 at 17:14

If every person on one side of the Earth jumps at the same time, it will not change the rotation of the Earth.

Similarly, the electrical and/or electromagnetic energy in or of your brain, while perceptible using EEG or other such instruments, does not make any noticeable difference in the physical world, in or out of meditation. It's relatively weak.

  • Can a fMRI detected citta – user12686 May 13 '18 at 16:48
  • @user12686 Sorry. It's EEG. fMRI detects blood flow changes. Take a look at this video by Tibetan monk and "world's happiest man" Matthieu Ricard. – ruben2020 May 13 '18 at 16:53

Theravada Buddhist Answer.

Conventionally speaking, yes mental phenomena might be described to have some kind of energy or momentum to them. Take anger for example, if its allowed to snowball it becomes completely uncontrollable, making beings perform unwholesome actions. In a way, one becomes a victim to anger. When anger snowballs, one can feel how momentum is build up.

Ven. Bhikkhu Bodhi describes anger as looking into a bowl of boiling water, not being able to see ones own reflection.

Having a still and peaceful mind is like looking into a lake with no surface ripples. One is able to clearly see the bottom of the lake.

Ultimately speaking, there are no such things as "energy or momentum" - these are concepts.

Here is a quote from a well written chapter, describing Ultimate Reality - its from the book "What Buddhists Believe" by Ven. K. Sri Dhammananda, p. 105-111:

The Abhidharma teaches that the egoistic beliefs and other concepts such as ‘I’, ‘you’, ‘person’ and ‘the world’ , which we use in daily conversation, do not adequately describe the real nature of existence. The conventional concepts do not reflect the fleeting nature of pleasures, uncertainties, impermanence of every component thing, and the conflict among the elements and energies intrinsic in all animate or inanimate things. The Abhidharma doctrine gives a clear exposition of the ultimate nature of human beings and brings the analysis of the human condition further than other studies known to them.

The Abhidharma deals with realities existing in the ultimate sense, or paramattha dhamma in Pali. There are four such realities:

  1. Citta, mind or consciousness, defined as ‘that which knows or experiences’ an object. Citta occurs as distinct momentary states of consciousness.

  2. Cetasika, the mental factors that arise and occur along with the citta.

  3. Rupa, physical phenomenon or material form.

  4. Nirvana, the unconditioned state of bliss which is the final goal.

Citta, the cetasika, and rupa are conditioned realities. They arise because of conditions, and will disappear when the conditions sustaining them cease to continue to do so. They are impermanent states. Nirvana, on the other hand, is an unconditioned reality. It does not arise and, therefore, does not fall away. These four realities can be experienced regardless of the names we may choose to give them. Other than these realities, everything—be they within ourselves or without, whether in the past, present or future, whether coarse or subtle, low or lofty, far or near—is a concept and not the ultimate reality.

Citta, cetasika, and Nirvana are also called nama. Nirvana is an unconditioned nama. The two conditioned nama, that is, citta and cetasika, together with rupa (form), make up psychophysical organisms, including human beings. Both mind and matter, or nama-rupa, are analysed in Abhidharma as though under a microscope. Events connected with the process of birth and death are explained in detail. The Abhidharma clarifies intricate points of the Dharma and enables the arising of an understanding of reality, thereby setting forth in clear terms the Path of Emancipation. The realization we gain from the Abhidharma with regard to our lives and the world is not to be understood in a conventional sense, but is an absolute reality.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.