2

I am a student of art and I am studying on Buddhist art .In the Vihara of Bhaja there is a decorated wall with two important gods of Hindusim, namely Surya and Indra. It refers to the Shunga period.

  • Why they have used images from Hindu gods?
  • Why would they have made this kind of art at all?

I thought that Buddha was against Hindu gods, and that people should follow him because Buddha advised that people should rely on themselves and not on the gods!

enter image description here

  • 1
    How do you know it's Indra? Maybe it's Sakka riding the Eravana... – Andrei Volkov Nov 9 '15 at 20:46
  • The question is that how have made this kind of art ? in fact, Buddha was against Hindu gods and people should follow from him because Buddha advised that the man should rely on himself not the gods! – saeed Nov 9 '15 at 21:02
  • 1
    The book referenced in footnote #13 on en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhaja_Caves claims it's Indra. – ChrisW Nov 9 '15 at 21:16
  • 3
    yeah, I checked the book and did some googling around before commenting... How does the book know it's Indra? – Andrei Volkov Nov 9 '15 at 22:06
1

From Wikipedia, Buddhism and Hinduism:

Hinduism and Buddhism, have common origins in the Ganges culture of northern India during the so-called "second urbanisation" around 500 BCE. They have shared parallel beliefs that have existed side by side, but also pronounced differences.

The Bhaja Caves date to around 200 BCE, so at the time of the relief carvings, Buddhism would only have been around for roughly 300 years. At this point Buddhism would have been considered fairly "young", and would have lacked as much of the independent symbolism, art, etc. that we see today (after the passage of ~2,200 years).

Within the first 300 years of Buddhism, mainstream society in India would still have been very much Hindu-oriented. Hinduism would have been everywhere, reflected in all aspects of daily life. So it follows that artists would have used familiar symbolism and artistic subjects, taken from the Hindu-driven mainstream culture.

This is, of course, as good a guess as any. We'll never know that specific artist's personal motivations or the circumstances that led to the choice of those particular carvings. But looking back on the period holistically, I don't think it's too surprising that we'd see a lot of Hindu art everywhere, even in and around "Buddhist sites".

  • i think your answer is not correct because in this time there wasnot iconography in Hinddu culture. thanks – saeed Nov 9 '15 at 21:09
  • 1
    Buddhists & Jains share a lot of common mythology and philosophy with what is today called Hinduism. The devtas(gods) have always existed in all these traditions before they were carved into rocks & walls. Just because they might have been carved at a later stage doesn't mean they didn't exist before – Bharat Nov 9 '15 at 23:34
0

As to Buddhism there is a kind of beings who are much like Gods that you mention they were given the name "Deva".

As to Lord Buddha there are 2 Devas with the power and authority over moon and the sun.

The one with power and authority over sun is called - Soorya/Surya divya putta.

If you are referring to the One upon the elephant please know that "Indra" is not the only one on a elephant.There is another called "Sumana saman" (Praised to this day in Sri Lanka) who met lord Buddha personally and made a temple himself.

And you have got one this wrong.Lord Buddha was not against all gods! Lord Buddha was against the belief that a being created the world/universe.So Lord Buddha was only against "Creationism & its Gods and Almighty".

I like to remind you that many of the suttas (Teachings) in Buddhism begins with a mentioning of a god who visited Lord Buddha and asked the question which resulted the teaching.

And i would like to point out that god called "Vishnu" who is very famous in India is a name found in Theravada Buddhism.As to Buddhism these are somewhat alien beings to earth who accepted certain beliefs and resided in certain areas of the earth.Buddha even said it directly and went on to mention their society,planet,body structure and so on.Lord Buddha even visited them in their own planet.And they used to visit Lord Buddha every morning.

I do not know your religion so if i offended something you believe i am sorry.But for us Buddhists all the Hindu gods are either fake or beings from another planet.

The picture of your's does not contain any solid evidence to back up the theory that it is actually "Indra",as to my knowledge an elephant is a sort of a highly regarded animal in Buddhism and that person on top of the elephant could be anyone from a Kind to a Deva or Sakra (the king of Devas)

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.